STEPHNNIE ANYAEGBU v. FHI 360 NIGERIA
AdvertisementNATIONAL INDUSTRIAL COURT OF NIGERIA
(ABUJA JUDICIAL DIVISION)
(O. A. OBASEKI-OSAGHAE: J.)
FACTS
Stephnnie Anyaegbu (“the Claimant”) was employed by FHI 360 Nigeria (“the Defendant”) as a Human Resource Officer from 15 November 2012. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Defendant allowed staff to work remotely. On 19 April 2023, it directed all employees to resume physical attendance at the office. The Claimant replied that the new directive “will not work” for her, explaining that she needed to care for her younger brother, who had undergone brain surgery, and she did not resume. Her request for remote work was refused on 7 July 2023. She was subsequently queried, her response was found unsatisfactory, and a Review Panel was constituted to consider her separation. Her employment had therefore run for over ten years before these events.
By a Separation Agreement and Release dated 27 July 2023, the Defendant ended the Claimant’s employment for “repeated failure to obey lawful instructions”. The letter computed her separation pay of one month’s basic salary, together with her other terminal benefits, at ₦2,333,658.72. She was invited to sign, acknowledging the sum as full and final payment and releasing the Defendant from all claims relating to her employment. The Claimant, however, never signed. On 4 September 2023, the Defendant paid the sum into her bank account. She neither protested nor returned the money. About six months later, her solicitors wrote to the Defendant demanding reversal of the separation, an apology, payment of her entitlements and ₦500,000,000.00 as compensation. The Separation Agreement and Release thus stood as the Defendant’s formal terms of exit, which the Claimant left unsigned.
The Claimant then sued at the National Industrial Court, seeking, among other reliefs, a declaration that the termination was wrongful, an order setting it aside, her salaries and benefits from the date of separation, and ₦500,000,000.00 as general damages. She thus challenged the separation after having received and retained the payment.
One of the issues for determination was: Whether the Claimant is not barred/estopped from instituting this action against the Defendant, having accepted the redundancy/terminal benefits paid to her by the Defendant?
ARGUMENTS
Learned Senior Counsel for the Claimant submitted that the separation was effected without regard to the mandatory procedures in the Defendant’s Employee Handbook and Employee Discipline Policy (POL03011), which required every disciplinary step to be documented and communicated to the employee. He argued that the Defendant produced no such documentation, that there was no panel report, recommendation or review meeting with the Claimant, and that the Defendant’s reliance on accelerated discipline could not excuse that non-compliance. In essence, he contended that the separation was procedurally defective and therefore unlawful.
Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the Separation Agreement and Release made final payment conditional on the return of the Defendant’s assets, and that the Claimant never signed it. A unilateral bank credit, deposited without the other party’s prior agreement, is not a contract, a release or a waiver, and creates no legal obligation on the recipient. He maintained that a waiver must be a conscious and deliberate election to surrender a known right and that the mere receipt of money paid into one’s account without consent is not a free choice to waive legal claims. In his view, the payment, having been made without her consent, could not bind her. He further argued that estoppel arises only where benefits are accepted without protest and that the estoppel defence was misconceived because a termination effected in breach of the employer’s own disciplinary procedures and the right to fair hearing is void, and a right against wrongful termination cannot be waived. On this footing, he urged the Court to reject the estoppel defence.
Learned Counsel for the Defendant submitted that the Claimant had expressly and by conduct consented to the termination and was thereby barred from challenging it. Having accepted the terminal benefits paid to her, she made the termination mutual and waived her right to claim that it was wrongful. He added that the suit was an abuse of court process. Counsel argued that a person who is sui juris may waive a right conferred by statute or contract where the right is for his sole benefit. In his reply on points of law, he added that waiver may be inferred from conduct clearly showing an election to forgo a right. He therefore urged the Court to hold that the Claimant was estopped from maintaining the action and to resolve the issue in the Defendant’s favour.
DECISION OF THE COURT
In resolving the issue, the Court held that:
Where an employee accepts terminal benefits without protest after the employment has ended, he/she cannot later complain that the contract was improperly determined. The Court explained that such acceptance renders the determination mutual, and estoppel by conduct bars the employee from challenging the termination. A person who is sui juris waives a right conferred for his sole benefit by accepting such benefits as full and final payment.
The Court further explained that a person who is sui juris can waive a right conferred by statute or contract where the right is for his sole benefit. The Claimant, having accepted her separation pay and terminal benefits without protest, is precluded from alleging improper termination of her employment, having been paid one month’s basic salary in lieu of notice together with her terminal benefits. Having waived her right, she is estopped from alleging that the Defendant failed to comply with its employee discipline policy guidelines, directives and applicable workplace regulations in her separation and release.
Issue resolved in favour of the Defendant.
Adeola Adedipe, SAN, with Samuel Fagade, Esq., Isabella Egwaelu, Esq., Mark-Anthony Okolocha, Esq. and Immaculata Obi, Esq. for the Claimant.
Tosanwumi Opubor, Esq., with Fortune Igrubia, Esq. for the Defendant.
This summary is fully reported at (2026) 11 CLRN in association with ALP NG & Co.
See: www.clrndirect.com | www.alp.company